Identifying a 45-star “Grand Luminary” flag (7/18/22)

Q: I have found an old U.S. flag in our church that we are trying to identify. It is approximately 13’ x 8’, with 45 stars in an irregular star pattern. It was found at First Baptist Church in Columbia, Missouri. The church was founded in 1823. The flag likely came from a previous church building built in 1891 and razed in 1954, but no one has any memory of it. Any help will be appreciated. — Ken Hammann
A: This is a Grand Luminary flag. The 45 stars are arranged in the form of one great star, a “Grand Luminary”, a design championed by Captain Samuel C. Reid in 1817. He is reputed to have called it “The People’s Flag”. Reid held it to be the star pattern that would best represent the concept “E Pluribus Unum”, the national motto (Out of Many, One). The Grand Luminary star pattern, (sometimes called great-star or great-flower) represents the idea of the national motto, each star is separate and distinct, yet all work together to create a unified pattern, a union of states. They were at the height of their popularity up to the American Civil War, but their use persisted into the 1890s. The 45-star count was current from 1896 to 1908. — Jim Ferrigan, curator, Zaricor Collection
Q2: Thank you very much for this information. It helps us begin to understand what we have. May I take a little more of your time with a couple follow up questions? How rare is this flag? Were Grand Luminary flags made commercially or custom? Is the flag valuable? Is there any reason to think that it is not from the period 1896–1908? Is the size of this flag unusual? Thank you again for your help with this. — Ken Hammann
A2: As it was made toward the end of the period in which the Grand Luminary pattern was used, the flag is relatively rare—and with 45 stars it is most likely from the 1896–1908 period (sometimes “anticipatory” flags were made, expecting more states, but that's unlikely with this flag, as the 44-star flag had been adopted just 6 years before). It appears to be a vernacular flag (hand-made, not commercially produced) and unusually large. It may have some value, but the size is a liability (framing and glazing such a large flag would be expensive). Utahns might attribute more value, as it recognizes Utah's admission as the 45th state. If you want a professional appraisal, you can connect to our past president, Dave Martucci, at http://www.vexman.net/antique.htm. If considering a sale, you could approach our commercial member Jeff Bridgman, a dealer in such flags: https://jeffbridgman.com. Of course, you could decide to display it, carefully, on important church/national occasions! — Jim Ferrigan